Inequality for Everyone…of Color
It feels immoral to summarize
observations that intimately dictate people’s lives. Most inhumane is the
transformation of those observations into numbers. Numbers themselves, mean
nothing truly but in contemporary society mean everything. Unfortunately or otherwise, numbers are often
easily understood and I will be providing them in order to summarize my
research on persistently low-achieving schools. There were very many schools in
the Bay Area classified as low achieving, which is disconcerting, but I focused
on two schools specifically - Alliance Academy and Roots International Academy.
Alliance Academy is a middle school
in Oakland helping 344 students ranging from grades 6th through 8th.
Alliance Academy’s student population is 72% Hispanic, 21% Black, 7% other and
0% White. 91% of the students are eligible for free or reduced price lunch
program. One must apply for this program and in order to qualify the student’s
parents must earn no more (annually) than 185% of the poverty threshold for
reduced price and no more than 130% to qualify for free lunch. The poverty
threshold is dictated by the U.S. Census and is based on annual salary. For a
family of 2, the poverty threshold is $14937; for each additional family member
add anywhere from $4000-5000 dollars plus or minus a few dollars. To clarify,
91% percent of the children come from families that barely make above the
Poverty Threshold as defined by the U.S. Census. Alliance Academy is situated
on 1800 98th avenue Oakland, CA. From September 24th to
September 30th of this year there have been 52 crimes in a 2-mile
radius from the school. These crimes include but are not limited to: Theft,
Burglary, Robbery, Vandalism, Drug and Alcohol Violations, and Assault (with
and without dangerous weapons). If crime were to continue at a similar rate, in
a month it will have been 260 crimes committed and in a year it will have been
3120 crimes committed. Not in the city,
mind you, just in the 2-mile radius from the school. What are the chances one
of these crimes affecting one of the 344 students attending Alliance Academy?
The progress of the school is measured through the use of standardized tests
and the scores therein. These are then compared to the state average to
determine academic progress and standing. The following numbers represent the
percent of students that demonstrated proficiency in specific subject matter
relative to their grade level in 2012. In 6th grade, 20% of students
were proficient in English and 6% in Math. In 7th grade, 21% were
proficient in English and 12% in Math. In 8th grade, proficiency in
English was 18%, in Math 20%, in History 13% and in Science 18%. The state
averages were 60% in English, 46% in Math, 52% in History, and 67% in Science.
Roots International Academy is
another Oakland Middle School; it serves 361 students. The population at Roots
is 63% Hispanic, 28% Black, 9% other and 0% White. 88% of the students are
eligible for free or reduced priced lunch. To, once again, clarify this
signifies that 88% of the families to whom the students belong to are living
slightly above the Poverty Threshold as defined by the U.S. Census. Roots
International Academy is located on 1390 66th Avenue Oakland, CA.
From September 24th to September 30th there have been 78
crimes in a 2-mile radius from the school. These include but are not limited
to: Theft, Burglary, Robbery, Vandalism, Drug and Alcohol Violations, Assault
(with and without dangerous weapons), Fraud, and Arson. If crime were to
continue at a similar rate in a month the crimes committed would be 390 and in
a year they would total 4680. Once again, these being committed in just a
2-mile radius from the school. Roots International Academy is held to the same
standardized tests and quantifying methodology as Alliance Academy. The
following numbers represent the percent of students that demonstrated
proficiency in specific subject matter relative to their grade level in 2012.
In 6th grade, 34% of students were proficient in English and 20% in
Math. In 7th grade, 24% were proficient in English and 19% in Math.
In 8th grade, proficiency in English was 27%, in Math 6%, in History
31% and in Science 24%. The state averages were 60% in English, 46% in Math,
52% in History, and 67% in Science.
It is easy to observe the parallels
between the schools and the circumstances described, by Jonathan Kozol, in
Savage Inequalities as to the two middle schools I researched. The schools both
share a non-existent white population. An environment surrounds them both where
crime is prevalent. That being stated there are a few dissimilarities. The
schools in Savage Inequalities had very little to spend per student about,
$2000 to $4000. The Oakland School District is allotted a budget of $12,946 per
pupil. These statistics do not account for inflation, however. The two middle
schools have smaller classes than those portrayed in Savage Inequalities but
the Educational System still appears broken. Is it though? If so, how so? Why?
What does it need to attain success?